Federal High Court in Abuja
Federal High Court in Abuja Getty Images

ABUJA,— The Federal High Court in Abuja has affirmed former Benue State Governor Gabriel Suswam as the winner of the All Progressives Congress (APC) senatorial primary election for Benue North-East, delivering a significant ruling ahead of Nigeria's 2027 general election.

Justice Inyang Ekwo delivered the judgment on Wednesday in a case filed by Suswam against the APC, the incumbent senator representing the district, Emmanuel Udende, and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).

The dispute followed the APC's decision to replace Suswam with Udende as its candidate for the Benue North-East senatorial seat, despite Suswam's claim that he had won the party's primary election conducted on May 18, 2026.

According to the results presented in the legal proceedings, Suswam secured 131,083 votes, while Udende reportedly received 1,364 votes. Suswam subsequently approached the court, challenging the party's decision and asking that his victory be recognised.

In his suit, the former governor sought to overturn the substitution and compel the APC and INEC to recognise him as the party's validly nominated candidate for the senatorial district.

Delivering judgment, Justice Ekwo resolved the central issue in Suswam's favour, affirming that he had won the APC primary election. The court also declared the decision to replace his name unlawful and inconsistent with relevant provisions of the Electoral Act, the 1999 Constitution, as amended, and the APC constitution.

The ruling represents an important development in the political contest over the APC's representation of Benue North-East in the 2027 National Assembly elections.

The disagreement had emerged after the party reviewed its primary election outcomes and made changes to the list of candidates. In July 2026, the APC replaced several aspirants on its National Assembly candidate list, including Suswam, following a review process involving petitions and recommendations from its internal appeal committee.

The party maintained that the changes followed its internal procedures. Suswam, however, challenged the decision, arguing that he had emerged as the winner of the primary and should not have been removed from the list.

During the court proceedings, INEC's counsel, Anthony Malik, reportedly informed the court that documents submitted by the electoral commission showed Suswam as the winner of the primary. His legal team also urged the court to uphold the result and reject the decision to substitute his name.

The APC and Udende opposed Suswam's case through their legal representatives, who asked the court to uphold their preliminary objections.

The judgment now strengthens Suswam's legal position in the dispute over the APC ticket. It also raises questions about how political parties handle the results of internal elections and the extent to which their leadership can alter candidates after a primary exercise.

For political parties preparing for the 2027 elections, the case highlights the importance of following electoral laws and internal party rules when selecting and submitting candidates.

The decision does not concern the general election result, which has not yet been determined. Rather, it addresses who should be recognised as the APC's candidate for the Benue North-East senatorial contest.

With the court affirming Suswam's victory and declaring his replacement unlawful, attention will now turn to how the APC and INEC respond to the judgment as preparations for the 2027 elections continue.